Any further feedback on how to improve the project?
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:05
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
schools is a good way to start
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:05
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
students have no interests
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:05
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
it does sound pretty Interesting but the amount of space in schools is still limited, which may mean that quantity would still be a problem
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:04
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Perhaps you should have a chat with the people over at Edible Garden City since they’ve already been doing this and get their feedback.
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:04
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Just because students learn how to grow plants, it doesn’t mean that they’ll want to do it beyond the school environment. How do you intend to create a mindset shift so that people will actually be incentivised to grow things at home? As for careers, it’ll be a great introduction for students who might be interested, but are there really that many positions available in Singapore given our sparse farming industry?
Guest
2021-01-25 12:06:04
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Edible Garden City has a farming curriculum for schools where they build gardens and even pack and sell produce at the school’s farmers market. How will your program be different? https://www.ediblegardencity.com/teach
Guest
2021-01-25 12:02:33
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
-
Guest
2021-01-25 12:02:33
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Sustainability, students come and go, and so you need to constantly retrain students to take care of the farm. This should not add additional burden on teachers.
Guest
2021-01-25 12:02:33
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Great idea
Guest
2021-01-25 11:59:04
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Have you worked with SFA? One of their aims is to do farming, so that Singapore can be more self-sustainable (i.e. its goal is for Singapore to be able to produce 30% of our food by 2030. They even set up farming spaces in Henderson Secondary School, and also a rooftop carpark in Ang Mo Kio, I think. Oh, and I am a copywriter, and I once covered an event by JTC (specifically, JTC one-north). They are also really big on this eco-farming thing, or just anything that can help the community. I also got to speak to Mr Benjamin Ee (see this article: https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/cnainsider/benjamin-ee-edible-community-garden-dover-crescent-open-concept-10570964), who does farming in his free time at a rooftop garden in Dover. You can Google "Green Day Out @ one-north) Let me know if you are interested and I'll dig out the article for you! Otherwise, you can reach out to the Placemaking Team at JTC one-north. They are really, really proactive when it comes to social responsibility and community building.
Guest
2021-01-25 11:59:04
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Hm... parents who complain about "their children touching dirty stuff?"
Guest
2021-01-25 11:59:04
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes I most definitely do! It's fun (nobody loves being stuck in class all day) and it brings along great value. Many years ago, there used to be a campaigned called 'Adopt-A-Park", where schools could "adopt" a small plot of land in a nearby garden. We planted the flowers ourselves and that small plot of land was later called the Butterfly Garden! It was so enjoyable. We used to plant flowers, but how fun would it be if we could plant our own food, and then donate some, and bring some home? :D
Guest
2021-01-23 23:57:44
Oh this is going to be great! It's fun (nobody loves being stuck in class all day) and it brings along great value. Many years ago, there used to be a campaigned called 'Adopt-A-Park", where schools could "adopt" a small plot of land in a nearby garden. We planted the flowers ourselves and that small plot of land was later called the Butterfly Garden! It was so enjoyable.
Now... for your question on further improvement: During my time as a student, we used to plant flowers, but how fun would it be if we could plant our own food, and then donate some, and bring some home? Or we could get students to sell their harvest at some fun fair event. We used to have fun fair events at school where we sold stuff for charity, but I'm not sure about today. It sure was fun! :D
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:56
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
I was from De La Salle Primary school, which had that aquaponics area previously, your team may like to visit them and pitch the idea to them.
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:56
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Quantity of plants grown may be limited, may not be able to scale up and costs may overrun.
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:56
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, it is feasible. My primary school has a aquaponics plot where plants were grown, so I think it is feasible. This also can educate students on the life cycle of plants, and also provide plants for consumption. Maybe they can resell these plants to the canteen stall owners for a cheap price.
Jordain Tay Yu Jun
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Primary and secondary schools for a start as well as technology and farming companies.
Jordain Tay Yu Jun
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Finding spaces for eco-farming in schools, types of food to plant, technology associated with it, Weather in singapore if it it suitable, trying to train relevant stakeholders to organise these session
Jordain Tay Yu Jun
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes it appeals to me and is feasible as it is pertinent as farming is something not familiar and done reguarly by us so it can be serve as a dual purpose, ensuring that we try our hand at something new and increasing food sustainability
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Not that I know of for now.
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Sustainability for long term. Public support and awareness are much lacking
Guest
2021-01-22 11:33:55
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
To a certain extend, yes. Space is always an concern.
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
HDB! look into community gardens etc
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Once people do grow up (live the 9-5 life etc), this may not be something feasible to them
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Inculcating this awareness in schools is great but how many students have the resources (and interest) to do this at home? It may just end up being a one time thing for many
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
HDB! look into community gardens etc
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Once people do grow up (live the 9-5 life etc), this may not be something feasible to them
Guest
2021-01-22 11:23:54
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Inculcating this awareness in schools is great but how many students have the resources (and interest) to do this at home? It may just end up being a one time thing for many
Guest
2021-01-22 00:37:27
work with GRCs etc to come up with community projects/competitions/educational session. Could also target elderly at old folks centers. Inculcating this “hobby” among families is impt, when adults teach children it becomes a bonding activity And makes it easier for the child to sustain their hobby with the support of grownups around. I think marketing outreach could defo expand as such
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:17
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Need not just be secondary schools, can also approach other levels (primary, JC, Poly, ITE etc.). Can approach HDB to pitch the idea in the form of community gardens (e.g. on rooftops) - target older audiences.
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:17
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Participation from a very small (and niche) group of students if the programme is not rolled out to all students; alternatively, how can you involve all students in a school? (Hundreds of people, but can the space in a school support a garden/gardens big enough for everyone to contribute?)
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:16
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, and yes. Manpower and location is largely settled, and I'm positive of the support from local farmers. Tying it with schools' curriculum/programmes can also be an impetus for students to participate
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:16
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Need not just be secondary schools, can also approach other levels (primary, JC, Poly, ITE etc.). Can approach HDB to pitch the idea in the form of community gardens (e.g. on rooftops) - target older audiences.
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:16
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Participation from a very small (and niche) group of students if the programme is not rolled out to all students; alternatively, how can you involve all students in a school? (Hundreds of people, but can the space in a school support a garden/gardens big enough for everyone to contribute?)
Guest
2021-01-21 10:38:16
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, and yes. Manpower and location is largely settled, and I'm positive of the support from local farmers. Tying it with schools' curriculum/programmes can also be an impetus for students to participate
Guest
2021-01-20 15:34:28
In the 90s, primary schools had areas carved out for farming and poultry rearing, which tied into curriculum. Perhaps this can be a perspective to consider.
Huey Ning
2021-01-19 10:23:49
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Local farms should also inclue poultry farms and not just vegetables farm.
Huey Ning
2021-01-19 10:23:49
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Who will exactly be managing the farming plot of land in the school? To ensure that students get a full experience, I believe that they should be the ones managing the plot of land themselves along with some minor guidance from the gardener. Plants that have been planted should also grow quickly and have visible/edible fruits of labour so that students would feel gratified and perhaps grow more interest in farming.
Huey Ning
2021-01-19 10:23:49
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes this idea appeals to me. However, raising awareness among students will not be very effective as most singaporean parents would disapprove of their children's interest to farming as a job. Thus, the yarget audience should be boardened to include the adults in singapore.
Guest
2021-01-19 10:23:48
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Carparks
Guest
2021-01-19 10:23:48
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
the concerns regarding people in this vicinity , like the students. If such a thing is to be carried out in school's garden, outsiders might have to interfere . Otherwise, schools have to pay more money for the workers
Guest
2021-01-19 10:23:48
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
of course, its is feasible. especially in schools, they are so much dead spaces that could be utilised to farm produces.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:29
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
nope
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Perhaps collaborations can be made with community centres or old folks homes to engage the elderly as well.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Upkeep of the plants on the weekends or during school holidays, perhaps there could also be an additional CCA club that continues to oversee the site and ensure that the plants are cared for and maintained. However this would mean extra resources are required.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, it is always good to start educating people at a younger age so they grow up with beliefs that would align with the sustainable development progress of Singapore and the world.
Tun Zen Yeo
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
You could look at the farms in Bah Soon Pah Road.
Tun Zen Yeo
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
The actual interest of the parties and of the students involved (either voluntarily or on a compulsory basis)
Tun Zen Yeo
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
I think of the various parties are willing to co-operate it could be done. It is appealing because I believe good awareness and behaviour starts from an early age.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
For mainstream schools, targeting those with a student care program could be a good idea as it can be part of their daily after school activities.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Getting schools on board as I think most schools don't have much dead spaces. I think getting students to think gardening is cool or fun will be difficult too (my school had a gardening club and you can count their members on one hand).
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:08
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
I think it's feasible as it seems relatively straightforward..
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Primary schools would be good too. Nil
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
The take up rate of local farms and local schools. While government is consistently pushing for more holistic education, its still very book based and some schools might feel that this initiative is not valuable and hence not take it up
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes I think so, I believe students can benefit from it and in turn the community
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Companies that may be looking to do CSR
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
An additional extracurricular activity may be challenging to manage this amidst students’ packed schedules.
Guest
2021-01-04 10:09:06
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
I like that it has the potential to cultivate a sense of ownership and bridge the relationship between city dwelling people and their food source by getting them involved in the process from young. It should be logistically feasible
Tun Zen Yeo
2021-01-03 00:19:15
I think you should try to also get government bodies onboard with this project too, seek some sort of recognition or approval from them.
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:48
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Instead of just secondary school, can extend to primary schools and junior colleges.
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:48
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Budget of the local farms and schools may not be able to support this programme. Farming habits in students may stay in school and not be brought home.
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:48
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes this project idea sounds feasible as it helps to utilise unused spaces in school and it is good to educate younger students on urban farming and instil awareness & interests in urban farming as an environmentally friendly effort and a career option.
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:47
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
consider pitching to shopping centres.
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:47
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
learning about it in school does not mean that they will take it home and implement it at home
Guest
2020-12-27 22:40:47
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
yes, because it is already done in many schools
Guest
2020-12-26 03:12:37
this does not really help support local farms? what is the benefit for the farms? perhaps only in selling hydroponic set ups.
Guest
2020-12-25 08:28:54
Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?
I think good initiative that youths today want to learn farming and i support your project and i agree that farming should be included in the learning journey curriculam in ITE, Singapore Poly and Sec Sch , SGE have a course of urban farming , you will check with SGE because i don't have info on hand .
I think some already mentioned that we farming like we visit a field trip to hydrollic plant or something if my memory recall .
Guest
2020-12-25 00:38:18
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Institutions that do psychosocial rehabilitation would be suitable to train clients on how to do urban farming. Many institutions already have these sorts of initiatives e.g. IMH patients cultivate and harvest organic hydroponics vegetables
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:51
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
high costs
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:51
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
yes. eco-gardens are found in most schools so this is very possible.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:51
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
can find out more from existing organisations who have been doing outreach to schools eg. edible garden city, foodscape, GUI -see how your idea would be different from theirs.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:51
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
how do the students 'share' the farm? given like one school is so big right? which student grp wld u target? also, do your team have the right capabilities and know-how to create this learning experience?
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:51
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
yes!!!! love the idea of bringing new life into 'dead spaces'
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Not sure what dead spaces schools might have that are suitable for this purpose. Some schools already have gardens/animals, perhaps for these schools it is more of building up the educational content.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, it is interesting and feasible! Good way to educate students on urban farming.
Zhong Han Lee
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
You could explore different types of farms - high tech indoor, rooftop and traditional farms!!
Zhong Han Lee
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Potential pitfalls might be that students go because it is compulsory and not take away much as they remain disinterested. One way to overcome this is to design the experience to be interactive and allow them to understand how these farms affect their lives directly.
Zhong Han Lee
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, the project is interesting!! Yes, it is feasible!! Organising learning journeys where students get to visit local farms is very workable.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
NEA, MOE, Fatming communities
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Already existing initiatives for this concept
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
yes it has already taken place when I was in primary school in 2008
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Can try pitching your idea to private schools such as Madrasahs, or even religious institutions like mosques and churches.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
This project may not get as much support from the public as you would like it to have. Better to start somewhere than nowhere though.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:50
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
As much as awareness is great, the main problem lies with the government itself. Land is scarce, and farming, although arguably more essential, will never be as profitable as other industries. Students want to learn subjects that are profitable. Make farming = $$$ and you would see much more support from all parties.
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:49
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
NIL
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:49
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Lack of space for farming at home
Guest
2020-12-25 00:37:49
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes, since rooftop farms and community gardens are rather common nowadays
Guest
2020-12-24 15:30:33
Yes, i do find that schools do not have adequate programmes on food so learning journeys are a great idea. But I'm quite confused wrt what is the objectives of raising awareness. What does the curriculum aim to achieve? How exactly this awareness and education translates into support for our local farms? Is the lack of urban farmers a true 'problem' that we are facing?
Zhong Han Lee
2020-12-23 21:28:52
Yes, the project is interesting!! Yes, it is feasible!! Organising learning journeys where students get to visit local farms is very workable.
Potential pitfalls might be that students go because it is compulsory and not take away much as they remain disinterested. One way to overcome this is to design the experience to be interactive and allow them to understand how these farms affect their lives directly.
You could explore different types of farms - high tech indoor, rooftop and traditional farms!!
Guest
2020-12-23 21:24:55
Yes, the concept already exists but for a USP offering your team may want to focus on the staffing and implementation of the programme and offering it as a service to different farms in Singapore by partnering them
Guest
2020-12-23 15:39:43
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Singapore Food Agency, Enterprise Singapore
Guest
2020-12-23 15:39:43
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Lack of awareness of the need of farming in Singapore. Teenagers may also prefer to engage with other programmes relating to tech and gaming.
Guest
2020-12-23 15:39:43
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Yes. I think there is a market demand for urban farming due to Singapore's vision to be better self sufficient. The idea is great as it inculcates farming to teenagers. They will grow up appreciating food sources and potentially reduces food wastage.
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
City sprouts. No contact but you see their instagram
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Lacks scalability as the produce generated is dependant on the school resources. This can barely address the food security issue.
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
50-50. It is not a new idea (although a good one). It's good for building awareness but limited in terms of call to action.
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "Are there other institutions we should pitch the idea to? If so, do you have any contacts with said institutions?"
Old folks home?
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
Wasted land , waste to the drains
Guest
2020-12-22 23:48:00
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
Who to look after on off days?
Guest
2020-12-22 10:19:32
In response to "What are the potential pitfalls you can think of?"
There may be no one taking care of the farm.
Guest
2020-12-22 10:19:32
In response to "Does this project idea appeal to you? Do you find this idea feasible? Please elaborate."
It's nice to see alternative programmes in school.
Contact Details